Holsters that fit the Springfield Armory Prodigy without a light
26 holsters from 5 makers. 4 confirmed by the maker, 22 listed with loose wording, 0 matched through a base model. Last verified Oct 15, 2026.
- 26holsters
- 5makers
- 4maker confirmed
- 22listed
- 0likely
Maker confirmed
$78.90
EDC Velcro Bag Holster for Springfield Prodigy
Black Arch Holsters
“EDC Velcro Bag Holster for Springfield Prodigy”
Maker confirmed
$119.95
Maker confirmed
$70
Springfield Armory Prodigy IWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy IWB Holster”
Maker confirmed
$75
Springfield Armory Prodigy OWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy OWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$114.95
Dual Clip Protos-M® 2.0 for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"/4.25"
Black Arch Holsters
“Dual Clip Protos-M® 2.0 for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"/4.25"”
Maker lists it
$104.95
OWB Protos-M® for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"/4.25"
Black Arch Holsters
“OWB Protos-M® for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"/4.25"”
Maker lists it
$77.95
Protos Heritage for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"\4.25"
Black Arch Holsters
“Protos Heritage for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"\4.25"”
Maker lists it
$104.95
Single Clip Protos-M® for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"/4.25"
Black Arch Holsters
“Single Clip Protos-M® for Springfield Prodigy 3.5"/4.25"”
Maker lists it
$79.99
Maker lists it
$44.99
Double FLAT | OWB COVERT Kydex Magazine Holder | CUSTOM | C&G Holsters
C&G Holsters
“Double FLAT | OWB COVERT Kydex Magazine Holder | CUSTOM | C&G Holsters | 2011/Staccato/Prodigy (Double Stack)”
Maker lists it
$44.99
Double FLAT | OWB COVERT Kydex Magazine Holder | QUICKSHIP | C&G Holsters
C&G Holsters
“Double FLAT | OWB COVERT Kydex Magazine Holder | QUICKSHIP | C&G Holsters | 2011/Staccato/Prodigy (Double Stack)”
Maker lists it
$39.99
Single UNIVERSAL | IWB/OWB Kydex Magazine Holder | CUSTOM | C&G Holsters
C&G Holsters
“Single UNIVERSAL | IWB/OWB Kydex Magazine Holder | CUSTOM | C&G Holsters | 2011/Staccato/Prodigy (Double Stack)”
Maker lists it
$39.99
Single UNIVERSAL | IWB/OWB Kydex Magazine Holder | QUICKSHIP | C&G Holsters
C&G Holsters
“Single UNIVERSAL | IWB/OWB Kydex Magazine Holder | QUICKSHIP | C&G Holsters | 2011/Staccato/Prodigy (Double Stack)”
Maker lists it
$150
4BROS Springfield Armory DadBod Appendix Rig
Four Brothers Holsters
“4BROS Springfield Armory DadBod Appendix Rig | Springfield Prodigy 5" / .093 Black / Right Hand”
Maker lists it
$150
4BROS Springfield Armory Prodigy RaceCar Appendix Rig
Four Brothers Holsters
“4BROS Springfield Armory Prodigy RaceCar Appendix Rig | Springfield Prodigy 5" / .093 Black / Right Hand”
Maker lists it
$87
Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" & X300 Duty & Competition Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" & X300 Duty & Competition Holster”
Maker lists it
$75
Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" & X300 IWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" & X300 IWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$75
Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" & X300 OWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" & X300 OWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$87
Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" Duty & Competition Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" Duty & Competition Holster”
Maker lists it
$70
Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" IWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" IWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$75
Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" OWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 4.25" OWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$87
Springfield Armory Prodigy 5" & X300 Duty & Competition Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 5" & X300 Duty & Competition Holster”
Maker lists it
$75
Springfield Armory Prodigy 5" & X300 IWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 5" & X300 IWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$75
Springfield Armory Prodigy 5" & X300 OWB Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 5" & X300 OWB Holster”
Maker lists it
$87
Springfield Armory Prodigy Duty & Competition Holster
Four Brothers Holsters
“Springfield Armory Prodigy Duty & Competition Holster”
Maker lists it
$64.99
Springfield Armory Prodigy 3.5″ Holster – IWB Kydex Holster
Muddy River Tactical
“Springfield Armory Prodigy 3.5″ Holster – IWB Kydex Holster”
How to read the badges
- Maker confirmed The maker names this exact model on the product page.
- Maker lists it The maker lists it, but the wording was loose enough that you should read the quote before buying.
- Likely fit Matched through the base model or base light. Most makers cut one shell for the family, but check the quote.
Questions
Which holsters fit the Springfield Armory Prodigy without a light?
26 holsters from 5 makers list the Springfield Armory Prodigy without a light, including Black Arch Holsters, Four Brothers Holsters, BlackPoint Tactical, C&G Holsters, Muddy River Tactical. 4 name the exact model on the product page; 22 are listed with looser wording or through the base model, and each one shows the maker's quote so you can judge it yourself.
How does holstercheck verify a fit?
I crawl each maker's product pages and record the gun and light named in the variant list or compatibility text. Every result shows that text with a link to the page it came from, and the date it was last seen. Loose wording is marked as such rather than hidden, and readers can report whether the holster fit their gun.